OPEN_SOURCE ↗
REDDIT · REDDIT// 14d agoNEWS
Conference appendices outgrow page limits
Long appendices are turning ICML and NeurIPS papers into de facto journal-length submissions. The post argues that if core claims depend on dozens of extra pages of experiments, the conference format is no longer serving its original purpose.
// ANALYSIS
This feels less like a formatting issue and more like an incentive problem: conference review norms now reward appendix-heavy papers even when the main text cannot stand alone.
- –Page caps only mean something if the main paper contains the essential argument, evidence, and limitations.
- –Once key experiments move to the appendix, “supplementary” material becomes part of the real submission.
- –The trend helps reproducibility and completeness, but it also raises the bar for smaller labs that cannot bankroll sprawling experiment suites.
- –A cleaner norm would be shorter conference papers with truly optional appendices, plus explicit journal-style outlets for extended versions.
// TAGS
researchicmlneurips
DISCOVERED
14d ago
2026-03-28
PUBLISHED
16d ago
2026-03-27
RELEVANCE
5/ 10
AUTHOR
kostaspap90